BrokerVA
BrokerVA Team · November 3, 2026

Hire-and-Cut: Why Mortgage Talent Is Cyclical, and How to Plan for It

Hire-and-Cut: Why Mortgage Talent Is Cyclical, and How to Plan for It

Mortgage staffing follows the volume cycle: lenders hire fast when rates fall, cut deeply when they rise, and then face the same question again. The 2020 to 2026 evidence shows boom, bust, partial rehiring, and renewed caution. Here is the pattern, its cost, and how to plan for it, as part of our mortgage operations staffing guide.

What Does the Cycle Look Like?

Each period leaves a mark in the reporting.

One caution on measures. The loan officer count in HousingWire's 2026 article (124,805 to 86,192) is NMLS data, which counts licensees. The 2024 article cites InGenius data on active loan officers, which fell from 181,656 in Q3 2021 to 89,094 in Q2 2023. Different datasets give different magnitudes, so compare like with like.

Why Does It Happen?

Because volume follows rates, and staffing follows volume with a lag. Cognizant, which sells lending operations services, describes the pattern this way: lenders tend to recruit and hire reactively, ramping up too late in booms and cutting too deeply in busts. That is a vendor's view, and it matches the timeline above. With forecasts that shift quickly, fixed headcount is always a bet on volume.

What Does the Cycle Cost?

More than the savings from cutting. Personnel is about two-thirds of production cost, per Freddie Mac's 2024 study, so it is the first place pressure lands. MBA reported production costs of $11,898 per loan in Q1 2026 and $10,936 in Q2, against an average of $7,945 since 2008. Freddie Mac sells digital tools, so weigh its interest.

Replacement is the other half. Gallup estimates replacing an employee costs one-half to two times annual salary, a broad figure from general workforce research. Cutting in a bust and rehiring in a boom pays that cost repeatedly, plus ramp-up time and lost knowledge. See The Cost of Turnover in Mortgage Operations.

Is It a Shortage or a Cycle?

In our reading, a cycle. Roles that were scarce in the boom were plentiful afterward, and the evidence for a steady shortage is thin: we found no independent data on which roles are hardest to fill, and vendor claims that name them offer none. Availability likely varies by role, skill, and market. See The Mortgage Workforce Has Shrunk by About a Third and Mortgage Hiring Moved Away From Signing Bonuses.

What Breaks the Cycle?

No single thing, and every option has trade-offs. These are our descriptions.

  • Planned hiring and training. UWM's chief strategy officer told HousingWire the company hires and trains people ahead of need, including people with no mortgage experience, and called it being overstaffed by design. That is one lender's chosen model and takes capital and patience, so it isn't right for everyone.
  • Cross-training and redeployment. Cognizant suggests cross-training and career pathways, and retraining processors into QA or exception-handling roles as automation changes the work. It's a vendor view.
  • Variable pay for producers. Better said it was shifting from fixed to variable compensation for loan officers and some operations staff, which ties cost to results.
  • Technology. It can lift capacity, but results are mixed. In the AARMR, MBA, and BCG survey, only 13% of respondents reported significant cost-reduction gains from AI, while nearly 30% saw major gains in employee productivity and cycle time. The survey is small and co-sponsored by an AI consulting firm.
  • A stable core plus flexible capacity. Keep what needs deep judgment in house, and add a layer that grows and shrinks with volume. See Flexing Operations Capacity With Volume and The Fixed-Cost Trap.

How Do You Size a Core and a Flexible Layer?

These steps are our recommendations.

  1. Pull 24 to 36 months of volume by month, and by stage if you can.
  2. Find your baseline: the volume you can count on in a weak month.
  3. Find your peaks and troughs, and how long each lasts.
  4. Set the core at the baseline, with the people whose judgment and knowledge you least want to lose.
  5. Assign repeatable work to the flexible layer, with clear instructions and handoffs.
  6. Set triggers for when to add or release capacity, and the notice you need.
  7. Review every quarter, and again when the rate outlook shifts.

What Should You Avoid?

  • Hiring to a peak that may not return. In 2026, lenders that staffed up early in the year are now reassessing.
  • Cutting review steps to save cost, since errors tend to return as cures and rework. See How to Lower Your Cost to Originate a Mortgage.
  • Treating flexible capacity as unmanaged, or putting credit decisions or independent QC in it. Even a flexible layer needs onboarding, supervision, and a clear scope.

Where Does BrokerVA Fit?

BrokerVA offers one way to build the flexible layer. We have 150+ mortgage operations specialists in five stage-based roles, Setup, Disclosure, Closing, Funding, and Post-Closing, and we provide tailored support for lender underwriting teams, preparing and reviewing files for your underwriters while the credit decision stays with you. We may be able to tailor roles to your business. Accountability for the loan stays with you and your licensed people.

Our goal is to lower your cost to originate. Every client gets a dedicated Coach for a 6-week implementation, who learns your processes, workflows, and expectations, then ongoing coaching and regular check-ins. We can't promise a specific saving, since it depends on your operation and volume. On a call, we'll walk through your volume history and show you our cost calculator live. Pricing is customized to your volume and the roles you need. See how BrokerVA works. In-House or Outsourced Underwriting Support? is coming soon.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is mortgage staffing cyclical? The reporting from 2020 to 2026 shows boom, bust, selective rehiring, and renewed caution, following the volume cycle. Staffing needs rose when rates fell and shrank when they rose.

How much did the mortgage workforce shrink? Among eight public lenders, combined employees fell 46% from 2021 to 2023, and average production employees per company fell from 555 in Q2 2022 to 337 in Q1 2026. Loan officer counts vary by dataset.

Is there a mortgage talent shortage? We found no independent data on which roles are hardest to fill. The evidence points to availability that follows the cycle.

Sources

Want to size a core and a flexible layer for your volume? Book a call with BrokerVA

BrokerVA | NMLS #1977844